By John R. Ellement, The Boston Globe
The state’s highest court ruled for the first time today that police can legally enter private property without a search warrant to rescue endangered animals, a decision that extends the same authority long used by police to save the lives of human beings.
“The question is one of first impression for this court,’’ Justice Barbara Lenk wrote today. “In agreement with a number of courts in other jurisdictions that have considered the issue, we conclude that, in appropriate circumstances, animals, like humans, should be afforded the protection of the emergency aid exception.’’
Lenk wrote that the Massachusetts has a large number of civil and criminal laws on the books that are aimed at protecting the health of animals from being harmed by humans.
“In light of the public policy in favor of minimizing animal suffering in a wide variety of contexts, permitting warrantless searches to protect nonhuman animal life fits coherently within the existing emergency aid exception,’’ she wrote.
But she cautioned that not every circumstance where animals appear to face threats will justify police bypassing constitutional protections against government intrusion onto private property guaranteed by both the state and federal constitutions.
“The emergency aid doctrine remains a narrow exception to the warrant requirement. Its application to nonhuman animals does not expand the exception or alter the essential framework for determining when a warrantless police search of the home is permissible under it,’’ she wrote.
“As in instances involving humans, there must be objectively reasonable grounds to believe that an emergency exists, and police conduct following entry must be reasonable under the circumstances,’’ the court concluded.
The ruling came in the case of a Lynn woman, Heather M. Duncan, who was being prosecuted for three counts of animal cruelty after police found the bodies of two dogs, still chained, in the backyard of Duncan’s home on Jan. 8, 2011. A third dog, also chained, was emaciated and barely alive.
According to court records, police did not wait to get a warrant, but instead entered Duncan’s backyard after Lynn firefighters had cut the padlock off a security fence that blocked access to the property so they could rescue the surviving animal.
A judge suppressed the evidence about the dogs during the animal cruelty prosecution on the grounds that Massachusetts law does not give police the authority to enter private property without a warrant to save animals.
The judge then asked the SJC if the decision was the legally correct, and today the SJC said that it was.
Kamu mungkin bisa saja bertindak seperti ini ketika bermain judi bola online di laga liga, tetapi kamu sudah terbukti rugi besar andaikan bertaruh dengan trik seperti ini buat Bandar Taruhan Bola Online Resmi. Melimpah pemain yang memiliki team andalan disaat memasuki golongan taruhan online dengan bertaruh di Bandar Taruhan Sportsbook Online Terpercaya. Tim dalam keadaan...
As a photographer, we all know how hectic and time consuming it would be to edit photos from Adobe Lightroom. And therefore, Lightroom Presets are excellent in regards to give your images the professional appearance. You might as well save a lot of time as everything happens in just a click. That is why, in...
Pendapatan adalah salah satu patokan yang hebat bagi para bettor untuk masih saja berdiri di dalam kehidupan judi online sbo. Mengapakah begitu? Ya karena bandar betting online sbobet dengan bahagia keinginan menyajikan bonus untuk para bettornya dengan nominal cuma. Situs slot pertandingan online seperti SBOBET selalu membuat promosi Chippendale New World Art Prize berhasilnya untuk...
Agen SBOBET Mobile Indonesia situs register betting sportsbook online resmi aman terpercaya di Asia. Login join taruhan situs SBOBET official permainan kasino & slot ALC. Bandar betting online kami dipastikan terpercaya telah bekerjasama dengan SBOBET online Indonesia. Oleh sebab itu SBO Mobile login, join, dan alternatif sudah bisa ditemui melalui agen betting online ALC. Agen...
If you come to a psychic practice not understanding what you need, a psychic won’t be able to give you accurate insights. Rose provides some excellent suggestions about how you can protect yourself from negative energy. A psychic reading is also an interaction between you and the reader. Our Mission. You should therefore cooperate by...