WASHINGTON (CN) – Halliburton and KBR failed Tuesday to have the U.S. Supreme Court kill a claim that it billed for bogus Iraq military-base services during wartime.
Benjamin Carter, a former employee of KBR’s reverse-osmosis water-purification unit (ROWPU) in Iraq, is the relator of the False Claims Act claims against the military contractors. KBR had been known as Kellogg Brown & Root when it was a Halliburton subsidiary.
Carter accused the companies of having billed the U.S. government for water-purification services on military bases in Iraq that they never performed.
He said Halliburton and KBR “knowingly made, used or cause to be made or used, false records or statements to get false or fraudulent claims paid or approved by the government.”
The Supreme Court was unanimous Tuesday in finding that it was improper for the trial court to dismiss Carter’s one live claim under the first-to-file rule.
This rule holds that “no person other than the government may intervene or bring a related action based on the facts underlying the pending action,” and the justices explained that the normal interpretation means that “an earlier suit bars a later suit while the earlier suit remains undecided but ceases to bar that suit once it is dismissed.”
Carter actually had three separate lawsuits dismissed under the first-to-file rule.
His first failed because a man named Todd Thorpe had a similar pending in California.
Though Carter refiled his suit when Thorpe’s case was dismissed for failure to prosecute, the trial court dismissed the second case because Carter’s first suit was still pending on appeal.
The complaint at issue, Carter’s third, was filed in 2011, more than six years after the alleged fraud.
U.S. District Judge James Cacheris invoked the statute of limitations to dismiss all but one of Carter’s claims as untimely. The final claim he dismissed with prejudice under the first-to-file rule, since similar cases had been filed in the intervening years in Maryland and Texas.
The Supreme Court agreed Tuesday that most of Carter’s claims are untimely, but it said the dismissal with prejudice under the first-to-file rule was “not called for.”
In this case, KBR had tried to argue that “the first-filed action remains ‘pending’ even after it has been dismissed, and it forever bars any subsequent related action.”
“Not only does petitioners’ argument push the term ‘pending’ far beyond the breaking point, but it would lead to strange results that Congress is unlikely to have wanted,” Justice Samuel Alito wrote for the court.
“Why would Congress want the abandonment of an earlier suit to bar a later potentially successful suit that might result in a large recovery for the government?” he added.
A three-judge panel of the 4th Circuit had rejected the trial court’s interpretation of pending claims as well but it had also reversed based on the Wartime Suspension of Limitations Act (WSLA), saying that law delayed the statute of limitations since the United States was “at war” when the alleged fraud occurred.
On this point, the Supreme Court reversed Tuesday, saying “the act applies only to criminal offenses,” and all but one of Carter’s civil claims was filed more than six years after the alleged wrongdoing.
The decision notes that Carter actually filed his lawsuit a fourth time, and that this case was dismissed since his petition for certiorari in the case at hand was still pending.
NOTICE OF DATA BREACH Dear User, We are writing to inform you about a data security issue that may involve your Yahoo account information. What Happened? A copy of certain user account information was stolen from our systems in late 2014 by what we believe is a state-sponsored actor. We are closely coordinating with law...
12:15am EDT Breaking News The hashtag #GasShortage is trending on twitter for Tennessee. It will soon be trending elsewhere. My brother reported to me a few minutes ago that Gas stations in Greensboro NC are out of gas and those truck stops have only about 7000 Gallons as of 1155pm EST. The immediate...
World Peace: The Final Chapter By Brooks Agnew Notes from 04 September 2016 World peace has been cited by pageant misses as their life’s work for more than a century. It is the stuff of happily ever fairy tales and Mendala shifting Disney movies. Guard dropping press releases misled Neville Chamberlain and countless other kings to...
Forgiveness by Luckee1 as heard on 30 August 2016 http://tfrlive.com/luckee-with-truth-frequency-news-66847/ I know when I was a girl, I was told that we had to forgive others. The adults, especially those associated with church, always talked about forgiving others. They also talked about how Jesus died for our forgiveness. They would talk about things like forgive your...
Original post is: Watch as amazing GcMAF treatment kills cancer cells in real time… holistic doctors ‘suicided’ over this stunning breakthrough A breakthrough cancer treatment appears to be the reason why a handful of holistic doctors were recently found “suicided” is now gaining worldwide attention as a potential universal cure for cancer. And new microscopic...